Contact Us
Indiana's Office: (317) 895-5555
Illinois's Office: (217) 215-0090

Welcome to Hittle Insurance

Our Agency was founded in 2010 by Melissa Lopez Hittle. At that time, we operated on a captive agency model representing exclusively Nationwide Insurance. Today, as an Independent Insurance Agency, we continue to offer Nationwide Insurance products, in addition, we have partnered with many other A-rated Insurance Companies which allows us to shop for the best coverage and price for you. online quick quotes

For over a decade, we have been servicing households and businesses in Hamilton County and greater Indiana. Our new office sits in a golf community located in the Bridgewater neighborhood. From your home or business, we are a one-stop shop and we partner with our clients to make sure they have the best insurance experience at the best price possible.

Let us help you with your insurance needs by calling us today at (317) 895-5555 (Indiana) or (217) 215-0090 (Illinois). You can also submit one of our quick online quote forms.

With the help of our licensed and dedicated Agents, we will get to work for you. Let's Talk Today! 

Hablamos Español & Portuguese.

Personal Insurance Solutions:
Auto, Home, Umbrella, Life Insurance
We specialize in insurance for high-value homes and autos, including collector vehicles, motorcycles, boats, RVs, vacation homes, valuable items, jewelry, art collections, furs, and more. Teen Driver insurance specialists.

Commercial Insurance Solutions: 
General Liability Insurance, Workers Compensation, Commercial Auto - including fleet, Commercial Property, Errors and omissions, Bonds, Builder's Risk, Employment Practices Liability (EPLI Insurance), Cyber Liability Insurance, and more.

Classes of Business we insure:
All Contractors - including high-risk classes. Also, Restaurants, Retail, Wholesalers and distributors, Professional offices, Veterinarians, Consulting companies, Attorneys, Auto services and repair, Churches, Self Storage Facilities, Aesthetic, Barbershops and Beauty Salons, 



Ready to Request a Free Quote? GET STARTED TODAY